Shopify vs Magento for B2B comes down to fit. Choose Magento if your ERP and your own business rules run the company and the store has to match them. Choose Shopify if your B2B is standard and a small team has to run the site. Three questions settle it: how custom your business is, how much data moves between your store and your ERP, and who keeps it running.
This post is the written version of our video. If you'd rather watch, it's 8 minutes:
We've built on both platforms since 2008, and we see the same two mistakes over and over. Some companies buy Adobe Commerce for complexity they don't have. Others pick Shopify and find out after launch that the ERP sync can't keep up. In both cases the platform didn't fail. The fit was wrong.
Comparing more than two platforms? Our Shopify Plus vs BigCommerce vs Adobe Commerce vs Magento for B2B post covers all four.
Rent it or own it: the one difference behind everything else
Shopify is software as a service. Shopify hosts it, secures it and upgrades it, and every store runs on the same core code. You can't open that code or the database. You customize through themes, apps and Shopify's APIs.
Think of it as a very nice condo. The building is maintained for you, and there are rules about which walls you can move.
Magento gives you the code. You get the whole codebase and the database. You can change anything, host it anywhere and connect it to anything.
That's a house you own. You can knock down any wall, and the roof is your problem.
Which Magento? Open Source and Adobe Commerce are two products
When someone says Magento has great B2B, ask which Magento.
- Magento Open Source is free, and it has no B2B module.
- Adobe Commerce is the paid edition, built on the same code. It adds the B2B toolkit: company accounts, shared catalogs, quotes, approval rules and company credit.
Our Magento Open Source vs Adobe Commerce comparison goes through the two editions in detail.
Adobe also sells a newer hosted version, and its core is locked, like Shopify's. So in this post, "Magento" means the versions where you get the code.
Shopify vs Magento for B2B: side by side
| Shopify | Magento Open Source | Adobe Commerce | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Model | Hosted. Shopify runs it | You get the code and host it | You get the code. Paid license |
| License | Monthly plan | No license fee | Priced by quote |
| B2B out of the box | Company accounts, price catalogs, net terms, quantity rules, volume pricing | No B2B module | Company accounts, shared catalogs, quotes, approval rules, company credit |
| Quotes | A draft order your rep builds | Extensions or custom work | Built in |
| Multi-level approvals and hard credit limits | Not built in | Extensions or custom work | Built in |
| Custom logic | Themes, apps, checkout extensions. The core can't be changed | Change anything | Change anything |
| ERP integration | Through Shopify's API, using a connector app or a custom app | A module can talk to the ERP directly | A module can talk to the ERP directly |
| API limits | Metered by Shopify. Plus gets up to ten times a standard plan | No vendor meter. Your servers set the ceiling | No vendor meter. Your servers set the ceiling |
| Hosting, security, upgrades | Included | You or your agency | Adobe's cloud or your own hosting. Your team still patches and upgrades |
| Best fit | Standard B2B, small team, scheduled ERP sync | Custom rules on a tighter budget, with a strong team | ERP-led business that needs quotes, approvals and credit built in |
Question 1: How custom is your business?
On Shopify you get a lot without writing code. Company accounts, price catalogs, net terms, quantity rules and volume pricing are all there. Since April 2026, the basics no longer require Shopify Plus. Standard plans are capped at three catalogs, though, so customer-specific price lists still mean Plus. You can extend it with apps and with checkout extensions. For a closer look at the feature set, see Shopify Plus for B2B.
The limits are real though. A quote is a draft order your rep builds. Multi-level approvals and hard credit limits aren't built in. And when you hit a wall, you can't change the core. You find an app, or you change your process.
On Magento, you can move the wall. Here's the kind of thing we get asked to build:
- For an aerospace tooling manufacturer, an estimated ship date on every product, cart and quote, calculated from the lead times in their ERP.
- For a networking equipment company, pricing that stays hidden until an account is approved.
- For an equipment manufacturer, parts mapped to serial numbers. A dealer types in a serial number and sees only the parts that fit that machine.
None of that is unusual on Magento. It's code written into the store. The cost is that you own that code through every upgrade.
The takeaway: if your pricing, checkout or catalog works in a way nobody else's does, that points to Magento. If it's standard B2B, Shopify does it with less to maintain.
Question 2: How much data moves between your store and your ERP?
For B2B, this is the big one. Every B2B store moves the same list. Products, customers, contract prices and inventory come from the ERP. Orders go to the ERP. Invoices and shipping updates come back to the store.
On Shopify, all of that goes through Shopify's API. To use the API you need an app. That's a connector from the Shopify App Store, or a custom app. Usually there's middleware in between that translates the data and moves it on a schedule.
Shopify has good connectors. Its ERP program covers NetSuite, Business Central and a few others. SAP isn't on that list, so SAP means middleware or a custom build.
Shopify also meters that API. Think of a water meter on the pipe. Plus gets up to ten times the flow of a standard plan, and bulk jobs run outside the meter. For most businesses that's plenty. If you have fifty thousand SKUs and a contract price for every customer, it's something you design around. And prices generally sync on a schedule, so the store shows the last price it was sent.
On Magento, the integration can live inside the store. You can write a module that talks to the ERP directly. There's no vendor meter. Your servers set the ceiling. So the store can ask the ERP for this customer's price, or this warehouse's stock, at the moment the buyer needs it.
The clearest example we have is a manufacturer on Infor SyteLine. The original plan called for an off-the-shelf middleware product. Their processes ran too deep in the ERP for a generic layer, so we built a two-way module instead. Customers, terms, inventory, lead times, orders and shipments all sync. The card is authorized at checkout, and it's captured from the ERP after the order ships. We've done the same kind of two-way build on Dynamics NAV and Business Central.
To be fair to Shopify, we're building a wholesale site for an eyewear brand on Shopify Plus right now, with a connector to their ERP. Their B2B is standard, so a connector is the right tool.
The takeaway: if the ERP has to answer in real time, or it carries logic no connector knows about, that's Magento. If you need a clean scheduled sync of standard data, Shopify with a connector is faster and cheaper. Either way, our ERP integration services team can map the data before you commit.
Question 3: Who keeps it running?
On Shopify, hosting, security, PCI and upgrades are included. Shopify Plus is a monthly plan on a multi-year term, and bigger stores may pay a variable fee on top, so ask about it before you sign.
Magento Open Source has no license fee. Adobe Commerce is priced by quote. Either way, when you control the code, you or your agency patch it and upgrade it, and unless you buy Adobe's cloud, host it too.
Adobe shipped several critical security patches this year. They only protect you once someone installs them. Versions also age out. One release left standard support in August, and the current one is supported into 2029. So Magento isn't dead. It does need an owner. Our Magento 2.4 versions and end of support post tracks the dates.
The takeaway: if you have no technical team and no partner, that points to Shopify. If you have a team, or a partner you trust, Magento's on the table.
To compare what each platform costs over time, use our free Platform Comparison and ROI Calculator.
Pick Shopify if, pick Magento if
Pick Shopify if:
- You're a brand adding wholesale, or a distributor with straightforward pricing
- Your ERP has a connector, and a scheduled sync is fine
- You want marketing to run the site without developers
- You don't want to manage servers and upgrades
If that's you, talk to our Shopify Plus agency team.
Pick Magento if:
- Your ERP is the system of record and the store has to match it live
- Your pricing, quoting or checkout has rules that are yours alone
- You need quotes, approvals and credit limits built in, which means Adobe Commerce
- You have a team or a partner to maintain it
If that's you, start with our Magento B2B overview.
If you've already narrowed it down to the two enterprise editions, read Shopify Plus vs Adobe Commerce next.
Still placing yourself? We built a free platform quiz. It asks about your ERP, your price lists, your checkout and your team. It takes about five minutes and gives you a shortlist. No email needed.
Frequently asked questions
Is Shopify or Magento better for B2B?
Neither is better for every business. Shopify fits standard B2B run by a small team: company accounts, price catalogs, net terms and a scheduled ERP sync. Magento fits a business where the ERP and custom rules drive everything, and the store has to match them. The three questions above decide it.
Does Shopify have B2B features without Shopify Plus?
Partly. Since April 2026, company accounts, payment terms, quantity rules, volume pricing and up to three price catalogs are on every plan. Unlimited catalogs and assigning a catalog to a single company still require Shopify Plus. Plus also gets up to ten times the API allowance of a standard plan.
Does Magento Open Source include B2B features?
No. Magento Open Source has no B2B module. Adobe Commerce, the paid edition built on the same code, adds company accounts, shared catalogs, quotes, approval rules and company credit. On Open Source you add B2B features with extensions or custom development.
Can Shopify connect to my ERP?
Yes, through Shopify's API, using a connector app from the Shopify App Store or a custom app. Shopify's ERP program covers NetSuite, Business Central and a few others. SAP isn't on that list, so SAP means middleware or a custom build. Data usually moves on a schedule.
Does Shopify limit API calls from an ERP?
Yes. Shopify meters its API. Shopify Plus gets up to ten times the allowance of a standard plan, and bulk jobs run outside the meter. For most businesses that's plenty. A catalog of fifty thousand SKUs with a contract price for every customer is something you design around.
Is Magento still supported?
Yes. Adobe shipped several critical security patches this year, and the current release is supported into 2029. Older releases age out, and patches only protect you once someone installs them. Magento needs an owner: your team or an agency.
Not sure which one fits? Book a 30-minute assessment
Both platforms are great. The right one is the one that fits how your business runs, so don't decide from a video or a blog post alone. If you'd like us to look at your requirements with you, book a 30-minute assessment. We build on Shopify, Magento Open Source and Adobe Commerce, so we'll tell you plainly which one we'd pick in your position.

